Have you ever wandered over to your head of finance and told them how they should interpret the Small Business, Enterprise and Employment Bill of 2014-15?


Funny how comms people often find colleagues from other professional disciplines advise us about comms subjects of which they have little knowledge or experience.

Knowing how to tweet does not make a social media manager, any more than spending your pocket money on sweets doesn’t make an economist.

A little knowledge can give us an inflated idea about how expert we are in any given topic.

This is the Dunning-Kruger effect, “in which relatively unskilled persons suffer illusory superiority, mistakenly assessing their ability to be much higher than it really is.”

That is, they don’t know what they don’t know.

The communicator can respond in a few ways to these encounters

I bet this happens in loads of professions – I’ve certainly seen it happen in communications, digital and marketing: the best experts are those who know what they don’t know.

And the self-proclaimed ‘guru’ is very likely to be the last person you want to work with.

I’ll happily admit that I’m learning as I go: through trial and error, reading and talking to people who are doing good things, and working out where I currently sit in the many grey areas where there are no right answers.

When people ask or comment about something blindingly obvious, ludicrously stupid or anything that displays they have a only basic understanding of an area I have experience of – I take it as a win.  It reminds me I have an incomplete but considerable depth of knowledge that I’m proud to build on.

Here’s a doodle I did on this theme, from a comms recruitment angle. (I doodle and scrawl on comms and work stuff over at commscartoons.com if you want to take a look.)



4 Responses

  1. Oh yes. You may be able to hear the sound of bells ringing from there Hilary! Everyone communicates as part of their everyday existence which means they can tell us how to do our jobs. And they do. Ho hum. I can drive a bit. Might tell Mr Rosberg shrew he is getting it wrong…

    1. For some reason my phone converts ‘where’ to ‘shrew’. And for some other reason have called you Hilary not Helen. Conflating you with a former acquaintance. Apologies. Time to go back to bed and not pretend to know anything about effective communication! Phil

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.